Letter to Minnesota Senator Norm Coleman... RE: Stem Cell Research and Other Disability Issues
Sometimes one must correct good intentions that are ill guided. See my letter below to Norm Coleman in response to his e-mail about a new stem cell breakthrough creating them from skin cells.
From: Mark Felling [mailto:Mark@Felling.US]
Sent: Wednesday, November 28, 2007 6:01 PM
To: Opinion@coleman.senate.gov
Cc: Norm@coleman.senate.gov
Subject: Stem Cell Research and Other Disability Issues
Norm,
Thank you for the information! It was also good meeting you at the state fair at the channel 5 tent this summer when we were both on the morning show. (I doubt you remember, but I was the guy in the wheelchair who designs unique adaptive solutions for disabled individuals with limited use of their hands and arms). www.GimpGear.US
I was recently appointed by Tim Pawlenty to the Minnesota Governors Advisory Council On Technology for People with Disabilities.
I completely and wholeheartedly agree with all of your statements below. In whatever manner the research moves forward I am in full support of it. However, I also firmly believe embryonic stem cell research may have possibilities other forms of stem cell research do not it is important to leave all options available and continue to explore all available possibilities.
I completely agree with getting legislation moving forward that would provide funding ASAP for this kind of research and similar that involves adult stem cells. However, this legislation your pushing should in no way restrict the future possibility of also exploring options in other areas of stem cell research, including embryonic as the debate may change over time (especially as Mr. Bush gets out of office). In my opinion he hasn't earned the title of president.
The concern I had was that your legislation also restricts other possibilities. As you state below, technology moves much faster than politics and just as quickly as this discovery was announced it could be shown to provide less than ideal or optimal results. In my own designs they are constantly changing and improving and consequently maximum flexibility needs to be allowed for. Pushed through the funding now and get things rolling but do not restrict the possibilities of exploring other areas in the future!
If you ever like to discuss this in more detail, or other disability issues such as regarding adaptive technology (my specialty), I can be reached at 612-851-1040.
Mark Felling
Quadriplegic Engineer & Inventor, MBA
President, Gimp Gear by Broadened Horizons
From: Opinion@coleman.senate.gov [mailto:Opinion@coleman.senate.gov]
Sent: Wednesday, November 28, 2007 5:43 PM
To: mark@felling.us
Subject: Responding to your message
Dear Mr. Felling :
As someone who has worked tirelessly to support stem cell research, while at the same time respecting the ethical concerns surrounding human embryos, I could not be more pleased to let you know about an exciting scientific breakthrough that was announced last week.
Recently, scientists in
As you know, I have been working diligently in the Senate to promote stem cell research without getting stuck in the ethical debate that has divided our nation. Earlier this year, my legislation, the Hope Offered through Principled and Ethical Stem Cell Research (HOPE) Act (S. 30) passed with overwhelming bipartisan support in the Senate. This important step forward would permanently authorize federal funding for the kind of stem cell research mentioned above. Unfortunately, the House has not yet taken up this legislation, but I am hopeful this new breakthrough will reenergize the stem cell debate, and persuade my House colleagues to vote on the HOPE Act before the end of the year.
This new discovery proves that it is possible to move stem cell research forward without harming or destroying human life. This means that now, more than ever, Congress needs to provide scientists with the funding and support to develop and perfect these pioneering types of stem cell research methods. This funding will not only promote scientific advancement, but it will also offer hope to patients and families around the world.
Thank you for allowing me this opportunity to share this important update with you, and for your unyielding dedication to this noble cause.
Sincerely,
Norm Coleman
United States Senate

